On July 24, 2024, the U.S. Coast Guard spun into action near Matagorda, Texas, after two divers, Nathan and Kim Maker from Edmond, Oklahoma, were reported to have been seen surfacing about 15 miles offshore amid a storm. Once the storm blew over, attempts were made to locate the divers, but there was no trace of them.
The search for the pair turned into an intense operation with the weather intensifying, which has not been helping matters. The search efforts have drawn resources from all quarters, from aircrews in an MH-65 Dolphin helicopter and an HC-144 Ocean Sentry aircraft; on the water, a boat is doing patrols, hoping to find the couple alive. There is also a crew aboard Cutter Edgar Culbertson who are all hands on deck for this search mission.
Diving is an exhilarating escape, plunging into an underwater world teeming with life that most never experience. Nathan and Kim Maker, the couple lost off Matagorda’s coast, likely sought such thrilling encounters amid marine beauty. However, that thrill comes knotted with risks—sudden weather shifts can transform a dive from delightful to dangerous swiftly, as seen in their case.
The tragic incident highlights nature’s unpredictable power and why every diver must balance their adventure spirit with meticulous planning and respect for the ocean’s fickle moods.
Diving, while exhilarating, carries inherent risks—from unpredictable sea conditions to equipment failures. Under Texas law, the doctrine of assumption of risk becomes crucial here. This legal principle means that individuals acknowledge the dangers associated with certain activities and thus may limit the liability of service providers.
If an establishment warned the couple about potential weather changes or other risks but they chose to proceed, this could indeed mitigate the company’s responsibility. Conversely, if no forewarnings were provided—or worse, concerns dismissed—the establishment might still hold partial liability for not ensuring safer diving conditions or postponing the activity.
When things go wrong out on the open sea, maritime law comes into play. Taking the example of Nathan and Big Kim Maker, who disappeared while diving, there is a pretty big “if”: if it turns out that the dive operator or boat captain messed up by ignoring safety protocols or missing crucial weather checks, they might find themselves in hot water legally under maritime rules.
Here is what that means: even though divers like Nathan and Kim know there are risks, if the people responsible for their safety drop the ball, then they could be on the hook for what went wrong.
That is exactly why you would want a sharp legal team in your corner. They handle all sorts of legal situations—from hashing out settlements to digging into product liability cases where shoddy gear might have caused trouble. Also, you want to go with a local lawyer so you will be sure they understand local laws and the court system.
SMS Legal
N/a